Unpacking Brand and Conversion in E-commerce Design

June 12, 2023
5 min read

E-commerce is intricate and multi-faceted. Two elements often fight for dominance during the design process of any e-commerce store: brand and conversion optimization. While brand relates to the aesthetic choices and narratives that differentiate your business, conversion optimization focuses on the practical adjustments that encourage site visitors to take desired actions. Both are essential, yet finding the right balance can be challenging.

Brand is much more than a logo or color scheme. It forms the backbone of your business identity, extending into customer experience, company voice, and corporate promise. A unique, cohesive brand can foster customer loyalty, create emotional connections, and significantly enhance the overall user experience. For example, consider Apple's minimalist design and commitment to innovation, which resonates with its customer base, fostering strong brand loyalty.

In contrast, conversion optimization can be more immediate and quantifiable. By adjusting website elements like CTAs, navigation menus, and layouts, businesses aim to guide visitors toward making purchases or other desired actions such as newsletter sign ups. In addition, companies can use a range of data-driven tools and analytics platforms to monitor site performance and optimize conversion rates.

However, this focus on conversion can sometimes overshadow the importance of unique branding. Too much emphasis on data-driven UX practices might lead to an online store that feels generic, thus weakening the brand identity. But dismissing conversion optimization entirely can result in a beautifully branded store that fails to convert visitors into customers.

So, when should you prioritize brand over conversion and vice versa?

Exploring the brand vs. conversion debate in depth

The problem of prioritizing brand or conversion in e-commerce design has been the subject of much industry debate. Some firmly stand for a brand-first approach, while others prioritize conversion optimization. So, what’s the argument for each? 


Brand-first advocates argue that a unique and strong brand is an e-commerce store's greatest asset. Branding can indirectly but strongly impact conversion by fostering customer loyalty and repeat business. A strong brand identity communicates what you sell and who you are as a company, resonating with customers who identify with your company values and narrative.

This approach champions the idea that successful branding differentiates your online store in a saturated market and a struggling economy. It conveys your company's personality and tells a compelling story that can connect emotionally with your customers, making them more likely to remember and return to your store. 

A striking example of the power of branding comes from the world of streetwear, with the brand Supreme. They've developed a distinctive brand identity that resonates so strongly with their target audience that their e-commerce design leans heavily on their name, with less emphasis on traditional conversion optimization strategies.

Their website design is minimalistic, reflecting the brand's urban, underground ethos. Products are displayed without much fanfare, relying on the strength of their brand to sell items. In terms of user experience, the site's navigation is simple, with a focus on product imagery over detailed descriptions or persuasive sales copy.

Supreme's brand identity is so robust and their customer loyalty so strong, that they can afford to prioritize their branding over conversion in their e-commerce design. Their brand-first approach helps create a sense of exclusivity and desirability around their products, and this hype in turn drives sales, often clearing out their inventory within minutes of a new drop.

Brand-first advocates believe that loyalty and the repeat business it brings outweigh any short-term conversion dips that might come from prioritizing brand over data-driven UX practices. In addition, they argue that building a unique, meaningful relationship with customers drives long-term profitability, outweighing any immediate conversion benefits.


On the other hand, conversion-first supporters view conversion as the core of any e-commerce business. They would believe that no matter how strong your brand might be, if your website doesn't facilitate the customer's journey toward purchasing, the business will struggle.

Conversion-first advocates argue that applying data-driven UX best practices guarantees a user-friendly site that drives sales. This approach leverages analytics and user behavior data to tweak site elements, streamlining the purchase path and maximizing conversion rates.

Amazon is a prime example of how conversion-first design can be successful. Despite its utilitarian aesthetic, Amazon's user-centric design principles, such as one-click ordering and personalized recommendations, simplify purchasing, leading to high conversion rates and repeat business. This reinforces the belief that an online store's primary goal should be to sell, and every design decision should facilitate that goal.

Conversion-first enthusiasts argue that without sufficient conversion rates, any efforts in brand might be in vain, as low sales and revenue could lead to the downfall of an e-commerce venture, regardless of how strong or unique the brand identity might be.

These different viewpoints present a clear choice: prioritize either the brand or conversions, creating a difficult situation where brands have to choose one and give up the other while designing their e-commerce store. But what if we could find a way to harmonize brand and conversion, enabling them to coexist and mutually reinforce each other?

Balancing brand and conversion

An integrative approach to brand and conversion harnesses the strengths of both strategies – a strong brand identity doesn’t need to be sacrificed for a high-performing website, and vice versa. When done correctly, your brand can facilitate conversions by differentiating your products or services and creating an emotional connection with your customers.

Similarly, conversion optimization strategies can enhance your brand perception by creating a seamless and enjoyable user experience. This approach focuses on the overall customer journey, from the first interaction with your brand through to the purchase process, ensuring that each step is on-brand and user-friendly.

Brands like Nike have nailed down this balance, with their online store showcasing a strong brand identity while also prioritizing a seamless user experience. For example, individuality is a brand value for Nike, so incorporating a personalized experience, such as recommending products based on browsing history, connects their brand identity with their user experience.

How to achieve the balance

The journey to achieving a balance between brand and conversion requires careful planning, ongoing testing, and iterative refinement. Here are a few practical strategies that can guide this process:

  1. Seamlessly infuse your brand into UX: Integrate your brand into all aspects of your user experience, from the color scheme and typography to the style of your images and the tone of your microcopy. Utilise a design system to ensure all styles are applied consistently across your site, even for integrated features provided by third parties.
  2. Conduct regular user testing: Regular user testing can provide crucial insights into how users interact with your site, allowing you to tweak your design to better align with your brand and conversion goals.
  3. Leverage data for brand decisions: Use data not just for UX decisions but also to refine your brand strategy. User interaction data can provide insights into what aspects of your brand resonate most with your customers.
  4. Use storytelling: Storytelling is a powerful tool that can enhance your brand and improve your conversion rate optimization. This could involve telling your brand's story or using product descriptions that paint a vivid picture of the benefits of your products.
  5. Prioritize clarity and simplicity: While having a unique and engaging site is important, it should not come at the expense of usability. Ensure your site is easy to navigate and that the path to purchase is as straightforward as possible.
  6. Iterative design: Your site is never truly 'finished.' Continual refinement based on customer feedback and data analysis is key to balancing brand and conversion.

By exploring and implementing these strategies, you can create a harmonious balance that drives brand loyalty and conversion rates. This approach ensures your e-commerce site is a platform for selling products that embodies your unique brand identity.

Final words

Balancing brand and conversion in e-commerce design may seem daunting, but as we've explored, it's not only achievable but beneficial for long-term success. This balancing act is a dynamic, ongoing process that requires commitment, creativity, and a willingness to adapt.

Navigating this intricate journey can be challenging. If you need guidance, our design team is here to help you tackle these complexities. We specialize in brand, UI design, UX design, and conversion optimization, and we're ready to assist you in finding the balance between these critical e-commerce elements. Get in touch with us to discuss your design and CRO challenges, and together, we'll create an online store that brilliantly embodies your brand while effectively converting your visitors into loyal customers.


Subscribe to our newsletter

Be the first to hear about what’s hot in e-commerce and Shopify Plus. Straight to your inbox.